@Slippage I really appreciate you taking the time to write out the scans. The way you laid it out was easy to input into TOS. Thanks again.
No problem. I'm glad it helped.
I took a look at a few other videos today. I noticed TG primarily uses the hourly and commonly enters trades when the Moxie Indicator goes positive on the hourly. I noticed on the posted scan that the Moxie Indicator is already positive. Do you think it's beneficial to include the situations where the indicator is just below zero so that the trade can potentially be entered as it crosses above.
A few things here:
1. To find stocks that haven't quite crossed yet you can change the Moxie pieces of the scan to whatever value you want. Where it has plot scan = moxie > 0; you can change the 0 to -0.1 or -0.2 or whatever you want.
2. The scan code in my most recent post that has all the indicator code, not the trampoline scan but the other one, will find when Moxie crosses over zero -- when the arrows first appear on the chart -- if you prefer that. You can add that as another study on the scan you already built and set it for whatever timeframe you want. Like the other Moxie pieces, it needs to be set for the higher timeframe compared to the chart you're thinking about. Watkins scans based on that trigger, at least in videos he recorded two years ago.
3. Remember that Watkins only enters trades in the last hour of the day. I think that's at least partly because Moxie repaints. Moxie may trigger at 10am but by 2pm the price fell and the trigger isn't there any more. He doesn't start scanning until 2pm.
4. MOST IMPORTANT.... I found through watching his videos from varying time periods his entries matured and became more conservative over time. In his oldest Moxie Trader videos he talked about entering on the hourly trigger, as long as the other criteria are met. In later videos he talked about entering half position on the hourly trigger and the other half after a retest of support, usually the 50 SMA on the hourly chart. In his most recent videos on YouTube he doesn't enter any trade until the retest happens. That's why I figured I'd set my scan to just make sure Moxie is above zero and not really care when it got there. And it's why my scan looks for stocks that are very close to SMA 50 on the hourly chart. That way either they retested very recently or they're probably about to retest. I'm sure I'll end up adjusting my scan as I get more experience in this, especially if it's not finding the stocks he calls trades on.
It all depends on your style, though. Watkins seems to keep a large list of stocks, in Excel or something rather than as watchlists in TOS, and he checks on them at regular intervals with the frequency depending on how close to ready they look. It seems sometimes he's watching a stock for several weeks before it sets up. I'm not really interested in spending my time that way. I'd rather not see them until they're ready to trade. He does enter early sometimes in anticipation of the final pieces of the setup falling into place so there is some benefit to spending that extra time. Since I'm new to the strategy I don't want to bend/break rules yet anyway.
Again, thanks for all you continue to do. Please don't take the above as criticism - I used the scanner all day and loved it. I was just thinking of a way to ensure we don't miss a potential entry point when the Moxie Indicator goes positive on the hourly.
Don't worry, I didn't find anything negative in your post and I'm not the emotional type anyway. And it's natural different people have different criteria for what they want to look at and potentially trade.
Last edited: