@germanburrito I agree w/ you that Hursts like this one, give the "best" signals which are negated by also giving the worst. As I said to
@Ninja Bull, the speed of these type of indicators do provide a heads-up that something might be happening. Analysis of price action and other indicators can then be used to prove veracity and entry and exit points.
I understand the attraction for the speed of repainting indicators for scalpers. I post warnings only when new investors, who may not realize the risk, post a query.
@germanburrito, I have learned a great deal from your contributions to this forum and respect your opinions. Not to hijack, so maybe in a new thread, I would like to hear more about your opinion that every indicator is a repainting indicator to some extent. As a technical analyst, I put STRONG reliance on my SMI, IFT, MACD, RSI, etc, second only to price action. To my knowledge: these and all other non-repainting / non-MTF indicators never repaint after the candle closes (hence being categorized as non-repainting). I would appreciate hearing your discourse on why you think I am wrong.